Engage!

Critical Dharma for Thinking Minds

Action Research and the People’s Wisdom

I just started working at a climate research think tank at Worcester State University (yay! I got a job!). It’s called Climate Action Research Network. Our mission is to produce research that generates climate action. Practitioners of Action Research have very specific meanings and methods for how they define ‘action research’ (see Action Research+ Journal for more specifics). Generally, it means that we as researchers learn from people as they practice in different fields, tasks and ways of life. We observe and collect a ‘people’s wisdom’, the wisdom cultivated by the practitioners themselves. We collect their wisdom and insights with them and share them with others to facilitate ‘best practices.’ This made me think a lot about different kinds of wisdom that different cultures generate.

Buddhism is a particular culture that generates a particular kind of wisdom. To sum it up, I would say that Buddhist dharma is the wisdom of non-dualism. Non-dualism has many meanings and forms: emptiness, interdependence, dependent origination, shunyata, interconnectedness, karma, rebirth (in some sense as ‘interlinked ways of being, doing and becoming’), oneness, wholeness, inseparability, and so forth–there are many, many ways to define Buddhist non-dualism. Generally, it’s a philosophy and world view that values integral wholes rather than parts, does not ascribe essential existence to the parts, but only to the whole, which is ultimately indivisible.

Buddhist wisdom is only one kind of wisdom. There are many other kinds of wisdoms in human and ecological cultures. (Yes, think about that: each species has a culture and ecosystems are inter-linked collections of cultures). There is indigenous wisdom, the wisdom of thousands of indigenous peoples who have persevered their wisdom and ways of life for thousands of years. Each of these wisdom cultures are very distinct and interconnected with the lands and ancestors they come from. There is also Black wisdom, the wisdom of peoples of African descent, created and preserved in diaspora conditions around the world. There is women’s wisdom, queer wisdom, and trans wisdom, the wisdom of various genders. There are the wisdoms of all the earth’s religions, including Buddhism. There is the wisdom of the sciences, the wisdom of ecology, the wisdom of healers and the wisdom of the arts.

When the Non-Buddhists speak of the ‘great feast of knowledge’ that Buddhism should participate in, they often limit that ‘great feast’ to Continental philosophy, as if that is the only other wisdom out there besides Buddhism. I’ve rarely if ever heard critical Buddhists and non-Buddhists talk about ‘the people’s wisdom’, the wisdom of countless diverse cultures.

When we limit ourselves to only Buddhist dharma, we are limited to only one kind of wisdom, the wisdom of non-duality. It’s no wonder it often feels like Buddhism cannot speak to so many of the crises and issues we face today. Non-dualism is a form of wisdom that is not the most relevant in many circumstances. When applied, it always yields a particular result: non-dualism. That’s not always the most relevant or useful kind of wisdom for many situations.

We need to open ourselves up to the whole university of ‘the people’s wisdom’, and learn from all of it: indigenous wisdom, Black wisdom, women’s wisdom, eco-wisdom, the artists wisdom, the healer’s wisdom, queer wisdom, and so forth. I’d rather see western Buddhists let go of clinging to only Buddhist wisdom and learn from all the cultures of wisdom that have been developed on this planet. We need a rich ecosystem of diverse wisdoms in order to survive and evolve.

 

4 comments on “Action Research and the People’s Wisdom

  1. don socha
    2019/11/09

    Congratulations on your new job and thank you for your meditation on the philosophy of non-dualism. I look forward to learning about the fruits of your action-research in future posts and want to thank you for all of your work. For several months now, your posts, both past and current have become a mainstay of morning reading for me and I appreciate the opportunity to catch up on a daily basis.

  2. “When we limit ourselves to only Buddhist dharma, we are limited to only one kind of wisdom, the wisdom of non-duality. ”

    This is not true, it is not even close. And what of the wisdom of telling the truth (not lying) or the wisdom of freedom from anger, or the wisdom of a happy life.

    These views of Buddhism are so narrow and limiting, we will need to add the Noble truth, just the plain facts and truth. that will be wisdom enough, so don’t worry, be happy, now that wisdom for you.

    It looks like you do not understand non-duality, for you it is just a concept. Concepts are not liberating, Living a life of non-duality is more wisdom than you can handle. Just as Colonel Jessup said, “you can’t handle the truth”, so you turn it into a concept to criticize.

    • Shaun Bartone
      2019/11/09

      No, in fact I recognize the immense scope and power of non-dual wisdom. But I also recognize and appreciate other wisdoms from other cultures. You don’t seem to appreciate the wisdom of other cultures, which is all I’m asking for here. Are you so bigoted and sectarian that you can’t appreciate the wisdom that other cultures have to offer? It’s because of attitudes like yours that I left Buddhism.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Information

This entry was posted on 2019/11/08 by .

Archives

Follow Engage! on WordPress.com

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 535 other followers

Blog Stats

  • 152,441 hits
%d bloggers like this: