Critical Dharma for Thinking Minds


What is Dharma?.jpg

What is dharma?

Is dharma only ‘the words of the Buddha?”

Only the Buddhist or Vedic scriptures?

Is it “natural law”?

Is it “natural phenomenon”, like science?

Is it ‘truth”?

Is it only Buddhist ‘truth’? or could it be western secular ‘truth’?

Could it be western secular ‘truth’ that happens to be congruent with Asian Buddhism?

Or could it be anything that we perceive as ‘true’ or ‘real’?

Is it ‘reality’?

How do we define ‘reality’?

Is dharma merely a reification of what is otherwise ordinary factual knowledge (cause and effect, impermanence) moral values or superstition?

Is it anything that we venerate as sacred, as having coercive power to make us think and act in particular ways?

Is it a collection of norms by which we evaluate aspects of life?

Is it the ‘canon’ of authoritative Buddhist scripture?

What about the ‘Western canon’? Is that dharma too?

Is it a kind of thought experiment that makes us see situations in new ways?

What is dharma to you?

A further point is that no dharma, whether orthodox Buddhism or [post]modern dharma, is beyond questioning or critique. All dharma is subject to critical testing. So it almost doesn’t matter what you call it or how you define it; the point is that it must be subject to critique.

One comment on “dharma

  1. Shaun Bartone

    I have a provisional answer: dharma is governance, in the Foucauldian sense. Glenn Wallis calls it ‘the Magistrate.” It is a potent combination of power-knowledge—dharma, scripture, with discipline— meditation & thought constraints, constraints on speaking and language. For westerners, it operates as the self-governance of the Neo-liberal subject. It operates as a disciplinary regime by delegitimizing and precluding whole categories of thought and speech. One is not allowed to speak, to think, to critique or question the dharma outside of the discipline. One is not allowed to think outside of dharmic categories, to think about, and thereby legitimize, the categories of the ‘other-than-Buddhist.’ As a discipline, not only must one meditate for hours-per-day, without moving or speaking, but even in the presence of teachers, where one is supposedly in a dialogue, one must sit quietly, not move excessively or question anything that is said. The discipline of meditation posture creates ‘docile bodies’ that only receive and never question the power-knowledge regime.

    But the subject can oppose this discipline through counter-power, by ‘speaking truth to power’, by seizing the category “dharma” and using it’s power-to-legitimate to thereby legitimate whole other categories of thought and speech. The subject can thereby create a counter-hegemony that not only refutes but supersedes the regime of Buddhist dharma. It can create a counter-power of discipline by using the power-tool ‘practice’ to introduce new “practices” that legitimate other forms of being, acting, doing. This creates a whole new form of self-governance, the self-governance of the post-capitalist subject

    This is precisely how innovation proceeds in Buddhism when it is introduced into new cultures. When it was introduced to the West by avatars such as Chogyam Trungpa, he invented a new regime of power-knowledge, ‘Buddhist psychology’, and a new ‘practice’ discipline, psychological introspection and guru therapy, to adapt Tibetan Buddhism to western cultures.

    Repeatedly on this blog I have used the power-knowledge regime ‘dharma’ to create and legitimate whole new categories of thought and speech, e.g. ‘the dharma of Valerie Solanas’, and introduced whole new ‘practice’ disciplines, such as the Situationists’ ‘derive’ and ‘detournent’ and ‘jazz dharma.’

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on 2018/04/01 by .


Follow Engage! on WordPress.com

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 616 other followers

Blog Stats

  • 175,784 hits
%d bloggers like this: